Cookie Swap: Polenta cookies bridge the seasonal dessert gap
Some people note the change of seasons with a wardrobe switch, some with a final dip in the pool. I make the switch from summer to fall in a simpler way: I change my morning beverage. Every year, sometime in late September or early October, I will come downstairs, dump out the pitcher of iced coffee, and pour myself a steaming mug o’ joe. Once I swap iced coffee for hot, I don’t look back: Stews and soups replace salads, plates have more orange and yellow and less green and red, and desserts turn from fruity to buttery. But the seasonal culinary swap sometimes needs a softer transition. And so I recently found myself searching for a cookie recipe that would fit the warm days and cool nights of Indian summer, something to ease from summer’s light, clean desserts to winter’s hearty sweets. A cookie with some sweetness, a bit of brightness but also a little attitude, some texture. I trolled the grocery aisles hoping to find something new and different and got distracted by grains: quinoa, wild rice, couscous, polenta. Hmmm, polenta … I grabbed a bag, hit the produce aisle for some citrus and headed back to “the lab.” Polenta is ground cornmeal, similar to Southern grits and a staple in northern Italian cuisine. Preparation usually involves boiling it with liquid until it becomes creamy, and it’s often served as a side dish. It also works surprisingly well in baked goods, lending a slight earthy sweetness and an interesting texture to cakes, scones and cookies. I started with a basic shortbread recipe, added some lemon zest, and cut the flour with polenta, at first using half flour to half polenta. The result was, well, not great: After eating one, I felt like I was chewing on sand for an hour. But it was a step in the right direction – the lemon zest provided a bit of the brightness I wanted, but the plain sweetness of the white sugar left me a bit flat. For the next batch, I lowered the ratio of polenta to flour, added an egg for richness, lemon juice to pump up the brightness and some honey, and there it was, the Indian summer cookie I was looking for: toothsome, sweet, lemony, the texture the perfect mix of gritty and smooth. The honey lent a deeper and more robust sweetness than sugar alone, the egg and lemon juice added moisture, and the tweaked polenta ratio was just right, adding just a bit of sandiness that nicely contrasted the buttery dough. The children, however, were less than enthusiastic about my “old lady cookies.” Nothing a little mascarpone cheese couldn’t remedy. A quick mix of the Italian cheese, powdered sugar and lime zest sandwiched between the polenta cookies turned out to be a hit. The creamy, buttery filling adds coolness to the soft, grainy cookie, as well as a little fun color. Storing them in the refrigerator increases the softness of the cookie, and after a day or so, they have a cake-like texture. The dough is also quite versatile, and substituting orange zest and juice for the lemon and making a chocolate mascarpone filling results in a slightly sweeter, more “kid-friendly” sandwich cookie that still appeals to adults, the perfect precursor to the belly-busting dense and creamy desserts yet to come this year.Related Recipes
Most Recent
The Vandy, STL Barkeep team will open Off Elm in Webster Groves this fall
The cocktail wizards behind The Vandy will soon have another locus for …