Best New Restaurants: No. 7 – Polite Society
A meal at Polite Society makes you feel like you’re hanging out in some sitcom Brooklynites’ open-concept living room, not snagging a seat at a slick new restaurant. Owners Jonathan Schoen and Brian Schmitz spent more than a year renovating the former home of Ricardo’s in Lafayette Square into their dream business – a concept they’d been working on for much longer than that.
Polite Society’s three rooms are reminiscent of a shotgun-style brownstone with exposed brick, refinished hardwood and enough open, salvaged shelving to inspire a run on Restoration Hardware. Dishes are familiar, yet presented with unexpected touches – an herbaceous olive oil dip with aggressively caramelized Brussels sprouts or a lacquered halibut so delicate it melted into the accompanying miso-spiked jasmine congee.
Wine from the extensive cellar flows; the congenial staff offers friendly, professional assistance and is quick with a recommendation. The space can be loud as friends linger over drinks, chatting with neighboring tables. As with any good dinner party, there’s no sense of urgency to depart. Order another bottle and pass it around as you enjoy good company and Polite Society.
Catherine Klene is managing editor, digital at Sauce Magazine.
More stories like this
First Look: Morning Glory Diner on Cherokee Street
Cherokee Street will add a diner to its diverse array of eating and drinking establishments when ...
First Look: Balkan Treat Box in Webster Groves
Balkan Treat Box in Webster Groves, Missouri will open doors on Wednesday, Feb. 13, 2019.