We’re bewitched by every creative concoction coming out of Sugarwitch’s South City kitchen, but the Gideon ‘witch is our favorite. Every ‘witch is a feat of dessert construction: easy to bite into without cracking a tooth on frozen cookies or squeezing melty ice cream out on all sides. The Gideon is a chocolate-and-peanut butter lover’s dream with a thick slab of housemade vanilla ice cream stuffed with chocolate-covered pretzel chunks and pressed between layers of chewy peanut butter chip brownie. A layer of smooth peanut butter on the bottom adds creaminess and cohesion.
Sugarwitch, 7726 Virginia Ave., St. Louis, 573.234.0042, sugarwitchic.com
This article appears in August 2023.
