Eat this ice cream sandwich from Sugarwitch in St. Louis

We’re bewitched by every creative concoction coming out of Sugarwitch’s South City kitchen, but the Gideon ‘witch is our favorite. Every ‘witch is a feat of dessert construction: easy to bite into without cracking a tooth on frozen cookies or squeezing melty ice cream out on all sides. The Gideon is a chocolate-and-peanut butter lover’s dream with a thick slab of housemade vanilla ice cream stuffed with chocolate-covered pretzel chunks and pressed between layers of chewy peanut butter chip brownie. A layer of smooth peanut butter on the bottom adds creaminess and cohesion.

Sugarwitch, 7726 Virginia Ave., St. Louis, 573.234.0042, sugarwitchic.com