Recipe: Cyrano’s Café’s Creamsicle Panna Cotta

July’s heat calls for cool treats, like those created by Cyrano’s owner and pastry chef Carolyn Downs, whose sweets menu features an upscale version of a summertime classic you’ll remember from childhood: the Creamsicle, here reimagined as panna cotta. The silky custard brings the cold and creamy, while the Orange Crush syrup adds vibrant color and sugary nostalgia for a dessert that tops any you’ll get from an ice cream truck.

Creamsicle Panna Cotta
Courtesy of Cyrano’s Café’s Carolyn Downs
10 servings

1 cup whole milk
1 Tbsp. powdered gelatin
1 whole vanilla bean, scraped
1/3 cup honey
½ cup plus 1 Tbsp. sugar
3 cups heavy cream
1½ cups Orange Crush soda
Whipped cream
10 mint sprigs

• Combine the whole milk, gelatin and vanilla bean in a saucepan and let steep for 5 minutes.

• Heat the milk mixture over low heat until it is warm to the touch.

• Add the honey and 1 tablespoon sugar and heat until the mixture is simmering.

• Add the heavy cream and heat until it is hot to the touch and the sugar and honey have melted. 

• Pour ½ cup of the panna cotta into individual ramekins or serving dishes, leaving room at the top. Chill in the refrigerator for 4 hours.

• Meanwhile, combine the orange soda and ½ cup sugar in a saucepan and bring to a boil. 

• Reduce by almost half or until the mixture becomes syrupy. Allow to cool completely.

• Spoon about a 1/4–inch layer of the syrup into each ramekin.

• Top each panna cotta with a dollop of whipped cream and garnish with a sprig of mint.